Agnostic Condolence Practices
Overview In the current age, belief in divinity is diverse, ranging from absolute belief in one God or many gods to absolute belief in no God or gods at all. Furthermore, today many people grow up in a multicultural environment where numerous world religions exist side by side within a single community. It is somewhere on this religious path, spurred by the insatiable human hunger for scientific knowledge of the divine, that agnosticism was born. HAVE YOU CONSIDERED: If you have questions about the deceased’s religious beliefs, ask a family member or close friend who shares those beliefs. Most people will enthusiastically share their beliefs with others. Questions, questions, questions! Because questioning and doubt are an agnostic’s stock in trade, we might characterize the agnostic as “the uncertain” or “the skeptic.” Agnostics adhere to no particular religion and are particularly skeptical of any implication of the existence of a higher power, or “God.” However, an agnostic does not automatically rule out the existence of a higher being merely because there is no hard evidence to prove it. DON’T confuse agnostics and atheists! You may be wondering what the differences are between an agnostic and an atheist. An atheist believes that the only superior being is her own kind, the human race. There are certainly no gods or unseen forces in an atheist’s world. An agnostic, on the other hand, may sit adroitly in the middle of the seesaw, balancing belief in a higher power at one end with total disbelief at the other. Because sufficient scientific evidence does not exist to prove one or other, the agnostic is comfortable in espousing neither. At some time in his spiritual journey, an agnostic may wrestle with and indeed feel trapped by the need to make a decision to believe or not believe in a higher power. Indeed, unlike many religions, agnosticism freely acknowledges that humans do not and cannot know everything. Given the dearth of hard evidence to the contrary (and particularly the difficulty of proving a negative), an agnostic might choose to think it was virtually impossible for life not to exist elsewhere in the universe. Or he might conclude that “God” and the universe are one and the same. One is in for a looping ride in attempting to debate the depth of an agnostic’s skepticism regarding deities in general and “God” in particular. A simplistic example of an agnostic’s thoughts versus thoughts of believers of various other religions might be: Sikh: “Brahman controls time and space beyond the universe.” Agnostic: “Prove it.” Christian: “God is in everything, in every place, in everyone. He loves you.” Agnostic: “Prove it.” Atheist: “God doesn’t exist.” Agnostic: “Prove it.” Scientologist: “We are life-forms from another planet, reincarnated to Earth.” Agnostic: “Prove it.” Agnostics and Atheism; Charlene Tay, 2013 However, even in the face of an agnostic’s firm beliefs or lack thereof, ultimately thet great unifier Death makes his appearance. No amount of belief or nonbelief can keep him from the door. Regardless of one’s religious beliefs, death is a universally heartbreaking event. DO remember the man or woman, not the death. Death from an agnostic’s viewpoint Uncertainty about the existence of God, whether there is life after death and, if so, what that life might resemble, present a complete mystery—the ultimate unanswerable question—to the agnostic. Death is a part of life, and the agnostic, like many others, knows that facing it one day is inevitable. In fact, people with a firm belief in a deity or an afterlife might have as much difficulty as or even more difficulty than an agnostic in dealing with the death of someone close. Since nothing is firm in the agnostic’s beliefs, he probably would not have clear beliefs regarding death either. The agnostic may ponder what comes after death but never comes to a conclusion, mainly because any firm conclusion would be based on sheer speculation. The agnostic may picture death as any number of random outcomes drawn from various religions. Given this scenario, death could be anything: winged angels showing the way, a chamber of 72 virgins, a long slumber, even nothingness. The possibilities are unlimited and unknown to an agnostic. Things to do and say Approach the family of the deceased and give your sincere condolences. Give bereavement donations to the family to defray funeral expenses. Offer brief consolation about the loved one’s departure, such as “I am sorry for your loss,“ or “You have my condolences.” Follow by positively and briefly describing an aspect of the departed’s personality or something memorable he did or said: “He was the kindest man“; “She was the life of every party“; or “We always made fun of each other during lunch.” Be comfortable at the funeral, taking care to respect each and every faith present. Things NOT to do and say Do not mention “God” or any other supreme being in your consolation. Even if you belong to another religion, do not use your usual condolences or sayings such as, “God will watch over him,” or “I know he’s in a better place.” However, do note that while the deceased might be a follower of agnosticism, the family may well be religious; thus it is better to tread with extreme caution. Being agnostic is a personal choice; so if you do not know the family’s religion, exercise neutrality regarding your words of consolation. As with all other bereavements, the family of the deceased will likely appreciate your mere presence at the funeral whether words are exchanged or not.